When I was growing up, we had a special plate that we would put cookies for Santa on every Christmas Eve (a tradition I suspect my dad encouraged…after all someone had to eat those cookies!). The plate always sat beside the fireplace empty until then, which made me wish we could always have cookies on it. So here is my solution:
Click here for the pdf download!

Items Needed:
Worsted Weight Yarn
3.5 mm (E) hook
Tapestry needle
Stuffing
Cookie:
Worked in a continuous round
Round 1: Ch 2, sc 6 into second from hook
Round 2: Inc. in each (12)
Round 3: * Sc 1, inc * 6 times (18)
Round 4: * Sc 2, inc * 6 times (24)
Round 5: * Sc 3, inc * 6 times (30)
Round 6: Sc around, slip stitch into next, bind off and weave in ends
Chocolate Sandwich Cookie: Make 2 in black, and 1 in white. Place the white between the blacks and stitch together. *make the center piece light green for a mint sandwich cookie, or use light brown instead of black for a vanilla sandwich cookie*
Chocolate Chip Cookie: Make 2 in light brown. Using a dark brown yarn, stitch “chips” randomly then stitch both cookie pieces together. *leave off the “chips” for a snickerdoodle or sugar cookie*
Cup:
Worked in a continuous round
Round 1: Ch 2, sc 6 into second from hook with green yarn
Round 2: Inc. in each (12)
Round 3: * Sc 1, inc * 6 times (18)
Round 4: * Sc 2, inc * 6 times (24)
Round 5: * Sc 3, inc * 6 times (30)
Round 6: * Sc 4, inc * 6 times (36)
Round 7: Sc around on back post only
Round 8 – 22: Sc around alternating colors as listed below
8-9: Green
10-13: Red
14-16: Green
17-19: Red
20-22: Green
Slip stitch into next, bind off and weave in ends
Milk:
Worked in a continuous round
Round 1: Ch 2, sc 6 into second from hook with green yarn
Round 2: Inc. in each (12)
Round 3: * Sc 1, inc * 6 times (18)
Round 4: * Sc 2, inc * 6 times (24)
Round 5: * Sc 3, inc * 6 times (30)
Round 6: Sc around, bind off and weave in ends
Assembly: Stuff the cup and place the milk on top, keeping it inside the cup. Stitch into place.

I am definitely making these! Thanks so much for sharing!
My mom and I love to crochet. I am trying to branch out of my comfort zone of the simple single crochet and the blanket or scarves. Is this pattern available for download?
hey im just asking but what do you mean by increase i dont understand
Way to cute!! I am going to get my yarn out now.
Sorry it took so long to reply to everyone!
Meredith – I’m adding a download link now, I didn’t realize I forgot to add it!
Emma – An increase is just doing 2 sc in one space. If you’re a visual learner, youtube.com is a great place to find tutorials.
Cherie & Kimberly – Thanks for the kind comments!
Awesome cookies, almost too real looking, I am so making these but into ornaments, thnx for the pattern!
[...] Radish Roll Candy S Santa’s Cookies and Milk Strawberry Applique Sugar Cookie Ornament Squash T Think Pink Cupcake [...]
I love these! I have a request to make crochet baked goods for my grand daughters Christmas presents. These are perfect!